Re: [Rd] delayedAssign

From: Luke Tierney <luke_at_stat.uiowa.edu>
Date: Thu, 27 Sep 2007 06:14:22 -0500 (CDT)

On Wed, 26 Sep 2007, Gabor Grothendieck wrote:

> I thought that perhaps the behavior in the previous post,
> while inconsistent with the documentation, was not all that
> harmful but I think its related to the following which is a potentially
> serious bug.

The previous discussion already established that as.list of an environment should not return a list with promises in as promises should not be visible at the R level. (Another loophole that needs closing is $ for environments). So behavior of results that should not exist is undefined and I cannot see how any such behavior is a further bug, serious or otherwise.

> z is a list with a single numeric component,
> as the dput output verifies,

Except it isn't, as print or str verify, which might be a problem if z was an input these functions should expect, but it isn't.

> yet we cannot compare its first element
> to 7 without getting an error message.
>
> Later on we see that its because it thinks that z[[1]] is of type "promise"

As z[[1]] is in fact of type promise that would seem a fairly reasonable thing to think at this point ...

> and even force(z[[1]]) is of type "promise".

which is consistent with what force is documented to do. The documentation is quite explicit that force does not do what you seem to be expecting. That documentation is from a time when delay() existed to produce promises at the R level, which was a nightmare because of all the peculiarities it introduced, which is why it was removed.

force is intended for one thing only -- replacing code like this:

       # I know the following line look really stupid and you will be
       # tempted to remove it for efficiency but DO NOT: it is needed
       # to make sure that the formal argument y is evaluated at this
       # point.
       y <- y

with this:

      force(y)

which seems much clearer -- at least it suggest you look at the help page for force to see what it does.

At this point promises should only ever exist in bindings in environments. If we wanted lazy evaluation constructs more widely there are really only two sensible options:

     The Scheme option where a special function delay creates a deferred
     evaluation and another, called force in Scheme, forces the evaluation
     but there is no implicit forcing

or

     The Haskell option where data structurs are created lazily so

         z <- list(f(x))

     would create a list with a deferred evaluation, but any attempt to
     access the value of z would force the evaluation. So printing z,
     for example, would force the evaluation but

     	y <- z[[1]]

     would not.

It is easy enough to create a Delay/Force pair that behaves like Scheme's with the tools available in R if that is what you want. Haskell, and other fully lazy functional languages, are very interesting but very different animals from R. For some reason you seem to be expecting some combination of Scheme and Haskell behavior.

Best,

luke

>
>> f <- function(x) environment()
>> z <- as.list(f(7))
>> dput(z)
> structure(list(x = 7), .Names = "x")
>> z[[1]] == 7
> Error in z[[1]] == 7 :
> comparison (1) is possible only for atomic and list types
>> force(z[[1]]) == 7
> Error in force(z[[1]]) == 7 :
> comparison (1) is possible only for atomic and list types
>>
>> typeof(z)
> [1] "list"
>> typeof(z[[1]])
> [1] "promise"
>> typeof(force(z[[1]]))
> [1] "promise"
>> R.version.string # Vista
> [1] "R version 2.6.0 beta (2007-09-23 r42958)"
>
>
> On 9/19/07, Gabor Grothendieck <ggrothendieck_at_gmail.com> wrote:
>> The last two lines of example(delayedAssign) give this:
>>
>>> e <- (function(x, y = 1, z) environment())(1+2, "y", {cat(" HO! "); pi+2})
>>> (le <- as.list(e)) # evaluates the promises
>> $x
>> <promise: 0x032b31f8>
>> $y
>> <promise: 0x032b3230>
>> $z
>> <promise: 0x032b3268>
>>
>> which contrary to the comment appears unevaluated. Is the comment
>> wrong or is it supposed to return an evaluated result but doesn't?
>>
>>> R.version.string # Vista
>> [1] "R version 2.6.0 alpha (2007-09-06 r42791)"
>>
>
> ______________________________________________
> R-devel_at_r-project.org mailing list
> https://stat.ethz.ch/mailman/listinfo/r-devel
>

-- 
Luke Tierney
Chair, Statistics and Actuarial Science
Ralph E. Wareham Professor of Mathematical Sciences
University of Iowa                  Phone:             319-335-3386
Department of Statistics and        Fax:               319-335-3017
    Actuarial Science
241 Schaeffer Hall                  email:      luke_at_stat.uiowa.edu
Iowa City, IA 52242                 WWW:  http://www.stat.uiowa.edu

______________________________________________
R-devel_at_r-project.org mailing list
https://stat.ethz.ch/mailman/listinfo/r-devel
Received on Thu 27 Sep 2007 - 11:18:31 GMT

Archive maintained by Robert King, hosted by the discipline of statistics at the University of Newcastle, Australia.
Archive generated by hypermail 2.2.0, at Thu 27 Sep 2007 - 14:41:38 GMT.

Mailing list information is available at https://stat.ethz.ch/mailman/listinfo/r-devel. Please read the posting guide before posting to the list.