Re: [Rd] promptClass misses methods

From: Seth Falcon <>
Date: Sat 02 Dec 2006 - 19:03:51 GMT

Ross Boylan <> writes:
> That answers my question. The meaning was if "foo" is an S3 method,
> should one avoid defining "foo" as an S4 method. And the answer is
> no, it's OK. I assume one should strive to use the same argument
> names, although since S3 methods don't need to use the same argument
> names I'm not sure how that works (e.g. for S3
> foo.class1 <- function(x, a, b) but
> foo.class2 <- function(x, c)
> ).

I believe you _must_ use the same arguments. When calling setMethod("foo", ...) where foo is a function, but not a standardGeneric, the function foo becomes the default for a newly created generic and the signature for the new generic is taken from the formal arguments of the original function foo. Clear as mud?

If you want to use different argument names, then you want your own generic. That is ok, IMO. That is why we have name spaces. It only makes sense to set a method on an existing function (plain function, S3, or S4 generic) if it "means" the same thing [this is obviously fuzzy]. IMO, there is no benefit of sharing a generic or having a default function on a generic that doesn't make sense.

Here's an example of creating a generic out of the head function:

    > setClass("FOO", representation(x="character"))     [1] "FOO"
    > getGeneric("head")
    > args(head)
    function (x, ...)
    > setMethod("head", "FOO", function(x, ...) x@x[1:10])     Creating a new generic function for "head" in ".GlobalEnv"     [1] "head"
    > getGeneric("head")
    standardGeneric for "head" defined from package "utils"     

    function (x, ...)
    <environment: 0x1d56600>
    Methods may be defined for arguments: x

Now head() is a good example because it means something like "show me the first part of something". But your application might want a function named head that meant "what's attached to the neck of an animal". In that case, a new generic within your package's name space seems advisable.

+ seth mailing list Received on Sun Dec 03 06:41:29 2006

Archive maintained by Robert King, hosted by the discipline of statistics at the University of Newcastle, Australia.
Archive generated by hypermail 2.1.8, at Sat 02 Dec 2006 - 20:30:58 GMT.

Mailing list information is available at Please read the posting guide before posting to the list.