Re: [Rd] why is \alias{anRpackage} not mandatory?

From: hadley wickham <>
Date: Mon, 06 Oct 2008 08:55:14 -0500

>> It may not be much work for you, but I find any additional
>> requirements to the package format to be a real pain. I have ~10
>> packages on CRAN and having to go through and add this extra
>> information all at once is a big hassle. R releases tend to happen in
>> the middle of the US academic semester when I have a lot of other
>> things on my plate.
> O.K., but the discussion with Duncan shows:
> - the required information is already available (in DESCRIPTION),
> - one can think about ways to generate the page automatically for existing
> packages,
> - the intro can be short and should link to other pages or PDFs,
> - one should avoid doubling and inconsistency.

I'm obviously not going to object if it's done automatically, and I already strive to avoid doubling and inconsistency by producing most my documentation algorithmically. I think you are being cavalier by not caring about the extra work you want package authors to do.

>> Additionally, I find that rdoc is the wrong format for lengthy
>> explanation and exposition - a pdf is much better - and I think that
>> the packages already have a abstract: the description field in
> o.k., but abstract may be (technically) in the wrong format and does not
> point to the other relevant parts of the package documentation.

Then I don't think you should call what you want an abstract.

>> The main problem with vignettes at the moment is that
>> they must be sweave, a format which I don't really like. I wish I
>> could supply my own pdf + R code file produced using whatever tools I
>> choose.
> I like Sweave, and it is also possible to include your own PDFs and R files
> and then to reference them in anRpackage.Rd.

Yes, but they're not vignettes - which means they're not listed under vignette() and it's yet another place for people to look for documentation.



______________________________________________ mailing list
Received on Mon 06 Oct 2008 - 14:05:06 GMT

Archive maintained by Robert King, hosted by the discipline of statistics at the University of Newcastle, Australia.
Archive generated by hypermail 2.2.0, at Tue 07 Oct 2008 - 13:30:17 GMT.

Mailing list information is available at Please read the posting guide before posting to the list.

list of date sections of archive