Re: [R] MDS with missing data?

From: Jari Oksanen <>
Date: Thu 15 Jun 2006 - 14:13:27 EST

Dear Context Grey,

On 15 Jun 2006, at 6:42, context grey wrote:

> I will be applying MDS (actually Isomap) to make a
> psychological
> "concept map" of the similarities between N concepts.

So actually, how do you do isomap? RSiteSearch gave me one hit of "isomap". I only ask, because I've implemented a working version of isomap (not ready for prime time yet, but a proof that it works). If isomap already is available in R, I won't do anything more with the function. I don't understand the rest of the question, but isomap really may be able to work with NA dissimilarities: just replace them with shortest path distances via non-missing dissimilarities. In fact, you don't need but some ('k') non-missing dissimilarities per item, since that is how isomap works. Your dissimilarity structure may become disconnected, of course, but that's common in isomap.

If you mean that your raw data has NA, then you may select a dissimilarity function that can handle NA input and produce finite dissimilarities (I think daisy in the cluster package does this).

Somehow I feel I answered to quite a different question than you asked. Sorry.

> I would like to scale to a large number of concepts,
> however, the
> resulting N*(N-1) pairwise similarities is prohibitive
> for a user survey.
> I'm thinking of giving people random subsets of the
> pairwise
> similarities.
> Does anyone have recommendations for this situation?
> My current thoughts are to either
> 1) use nonmetric/gradient descent MDS which seems to
> allow missing data, or

Not the isoMDS function in MASS. if N(N-1) is a problem, then nonmetric
MDS may not be the solution.

> 2) devise some scheme whereby the data that are ranked
> in common
> by several people is used to derive a scaling
> factor for each
> person's ratings.
> Thanks for any advice,
> _

Cheers, Green Power

Green Power, Oulu, Finland

______________________________________________ mailing list
PLEASE do read the posting guide!
Received on Thu Jun 15 14:19:45 2006

Archive maintained by Robert King, hosted by the discipline of statistics at the University of Newcastle, Australia.
Archive generated by hypermail 2.1.8, at Thu 15 Jun 2006 - 20:12:17 EST.

Mailing list information is available at Please read the posting guide before posting to the list.