Re: [Rd] why is \alias{anRpackage} not mandatory?

From: Duncan Murdoch <>
Date: Tue, 07 Oct 2008 10:49:03 -0400

On 07/10/2008 10:17 AM, hadley wickham wrote:

>> This shows up in the HTML help system.  It would be better if it showed up
>> in all help formats, but there are other ways to do that, e.g. creating an
>> Rd help page pointing to those files.

> Or you can just link to them from your website.
> I don't think you'd argue with the statement that there's already too
> many different ways to find R documentation.

I think that's a paraphrase of one of my earlier posts.

> There are plenty of
> hacks and work-arounds to jam different types of documentation in
> different places, but they are just hacks and work-arounds. My
> feeling is that evolutionary modification of the documentation system
> is only going to get us so far, and at some point the entire
> foundations need to be rethought.

I don't agree with this. Back in 2001 when this was first proposed it might have worked, but there's far too much inertia now to make a big change. Weren't you the one who objected to a requirement for a foo-package help topic? How would you like to rewrite all the help files for all of your packages? (I imagine not much. I'm certainly not going to do that for mine.)

I think any change we make now needs to be incremental, but there's a tremendous amount of friction against anything at all, and very few offers of support to actually do the work.

Here are things I'm currently working on, that I'd appreciate support for:

> Of course, the problem is having enough time to do that, and then to
> code up the solution!

That's the main problem. I find the coding is much easier than the design, though. I can code on my own, but the design really needs careful thought and criticism. (It's easy to get shallow criticism; the hard thing is to get useful criticism.) That means at least two people need to find time to work together on the problem, and in my experience, that has almost never happened with any of the problems above. So I move very, very slowly on them.

Duncan Murdoch mailing list Received on Tue 07 Oct 2008 - 14:52:19 GMT

Archive maintained by Robert King, hosted by the discipline of statistics at the University of Newcastle, Australia.
Archive generated by hypermail 2.2.0, at Tue 07 Oct 2008 - 16:30:17 GMT.

Mailing list information is available at Please read the posting guide before posting to the list.

list of date sections of archive